My brother told me this morning of a study he read about online. Some scientists, he said, had theorized that it was impossible for men and women to remain in love for more than 2-4 years and that anything people consider love past that point was simply companionship and shared interest.
But, he relayed further, a group of long-time couples told these scientists that they were, in fact, still very much in love. The people responsible for the study tested the endorphin levels, thought patterns, and brain reactions of this group of couples and discovered that, lo and behold, they were still “clinically” in love.
Decades past the puppy love stage and into what is usually characterized by a working partnership, it would appear they were still twitterpated.

Today I slipped it off, my double band. It was only to wash a dish and then I slid it back on that left ring finger. I twirled it. Toward my palm, back to my knuckle.
He had it custom made back then, because he knew what I had dreamed of and he wanted it to be perfect. And then he surprised me the day he pulled the ring from his pocket. Truly, I was shocked.
But I said yes.
I spun the ring and pondered that study and those scientists and their theory and their long-married subjects.
And I thought back to that time when I wasn’t sure I wanted to keep wearing this white gold circle clasping a brilliant diamond – the stone with an inclusion that likely happened hiking through Alaska on our honeymoon.
I wondered about the couples in the study. I wondered of their stories.
Are they actually in love now? They say they are. The research says they are.
But I don’t believe any of them have always been in love, since day one.
In fact, I’d guess many of them have felt pretty well out of love at some point in their decades.
Enough that, perhaps, they’ve considered taking off their rings?
I was young when I said yes and wore the ring. So young. I hardly knew my own mind, let alone my heart. I did what was right, and I did what made sense. I did know I loved this man enough to wear his ring.
So I did.
It’s been over eight years since the day he surprised me with a ring
and I’m telling you now about that time I thought of taking it off.
I mulled it in my brain, thought of all the ways it would be okay. Was drowned by the reasons it wouldn’t. I imagined my life, his life, without these rings we wore.
But then
one day
I chose.
I chose him.
I chose him all over again.
This man, this old-and-young-and-not-very-wise version of love.
He fought and he won. He held my heart close and he wooed me to his shoulder.
He had certainly been the one to pursue me then, those years ago, and I was captivated by him. But now he caught my heart and soul again and it was my turn to really choose.
And I chose him.
Really chose him this time.
And now? Oh, now… I didn’t know there could be such a cocktail of love and companionship and history and life.
I’m imagining those couples and their stories tonight. I wonder how many years they’d been together when the love wore away and they discovered the truth of it.
Love is a choice isn’t just something our grandmothers said because it sounded pretty. They didn’t tell the young brides that love grows with age simply to make conversation.
They were right.
It is a choice. An every day choice, a hard choice, a heavy choice, an I-have-to-do-this-if-it-kills-me choice. It’s a happy choice, a beautiful choice, a supernatural, God-empowered choice.
Without that? An infant love never becomes a mature love. It doesn’t know its own strength.
Sometimes everything has to break in order to heal all over again. For the bond to be strong, it must be tested.
Is it possible to be so very in love after twenty or thirty or forty years?
Yes.
But perhaps not without first falling out of it.
I’m very aware that there are marriages where one partner walks away, no matter the choice of the other, and that there are relationships that break for reasons untold and unknown. I’m simply speaking of my own observations, my own life, and my own experience. I know you know that and understand.










Oh, beautiful. I just started reading your blog after being linked by BooMama and I am so happy I did. You are a wonderful writer and I am touched by the entries I’ve read – but this one hit me so true to life right now. Thanks for this.
[Reply]
I think all married people make that choice at some point. Love is a choice! What a blessing you are!
[Reply]
Oh my goodness, Ashleigh, you have me in tears. Like you, I said yes when I was young – too young? Debatable. I was only 19 when I said yes, 21 when I married. Last summer at 26 (right around our 5th anniversary!) I thought about taking it off for good. I chose not to, I chose to stay, and oh – you’re right. It makes all the difference, that second choice. I didn’t really *get* it until then.
You and John have always seemed like such a fairy tale to me. Thanks for sharing the reality of where your love lives daily… thank you for your honesty.
“Perhaps not without first falling out of it.” Oh, that line is going to stay with me for a long time. Thank you.
[Reply]
This is so beautiful. It really hits home. I married young, far too young, and looking back, perhaps it wasn’t the best decision I’ve ever made, but it’s the one I did make. And I do love him. It’s easy to become disenchanted; to ponder taking off the ring. It is about making that choice. To choose to love wholeheartedly. There is a reason we’re together after all these years and even though I don’t actually wear my ring (not for symbolic purposes, but because I like bare hands), I’m committed to my choice. It’s not always easy.
[Reply]
I think anyone who has been in a long-term relationship gets this choosing again and again, especially when the choosing means going the hard way and admitting you screwed up and hurt the other person and this choice is your own fault. It will be 13 years next month, and I’m just now beginning to grasp the hard work involved in staying in love.
[Reply]
this.is.exquisite friend…
[Reply]
You say it so well. Yes indeed, love is a choice we make every day. Some days it is harder than others. xoxo
[Reply]
This is why I love stories. Redemption is beautiful. Love is a choice. Sometimes it’s a hard, grueling, I-don’t-want-to choice, but the depth after the choosing again is worth it.
[Reply]
Jim and I have been married for fifty years come March 18,2012. We can’t wait!! We married when I was eighteen and he was 21.We have five children, 20 Grandchildren, 7 Great-Grand Children and with God’s help many more to come!! We thought when we married , there could be no greater love but……Through all the following moments, minutes, day, weeks, and years, we have found that that first young love has grown ever so much stronger. We have had those times of feeling “out of love” but never would we quit on purpose!! We have had really hard things that we have had to go through in our lives, but never would we quit! God has always been the ONE holding us together and He does not ever let go. Love is a choice as you said and it is a commitment for life if it is at all possible. I know as you do sometimes there are those who walk away, or are physically abusive, etc. Many reason why one can not stay in the bond of marriage. But…..for those who have a choice, I have never once regretted saying, “YES!” to a young man whom I had really only known for three months and three months later we were married. I had seen glimpses of him at my Grandparents home when he was a bout twelve. I thought at that time, “that is the most bumpy faced boy that I have ever seen.” I believe he is the most handsome, most wonderful man that I know. He is the one that I prayed for, starting from age 12 and I know God gave us to each other. As far as still loving,……loving seems such a simple word for what I feel for this man after all these years but I can say, it is the very best of love. He makes my heart dance, when I see him and when we are away from each other, his is the face, I seek. He has been my love, my protector, my provider,my shoulder to lean on, my burden bearer, my comfort. I know through our relationship what it means to be happy, truly happy.connie
[Reply]
gabrielle Reply:
August 11th, 2011 at 9:44 am
and this is where I want to be oneday.
[Reply]
Mishel Reply:
August 11th, 2011 at 7:49 pm
Connie this was so beautiful. I have always encouraged by your obvious love for your husband. Thank you for sharing what love looks like after 50 years. : )
[Reply]
Ash I’m in tears reading this and watching the video because you spoke my heart! I too have a story of the “choice” and it wasn’t until he left in July that I fully made my decision. Thank you for writing this to give me the strength to be honest too! Love you
[Reply]
Amen. Just amen.
[Reply]
Dear Brave One, maybe I’m still in the “pupy love” stage of things… I’m not quite understanding how love can be a choice…. but I acknowlege that I’m still young and dumb, and universly niaeve. I want to learn by observation. Youre not that much older than me, but its been plainly obvious since the day we met that you are wise beyond your years. Even if you dont feel it sometimes. I want to take this wisdom -or shall I say warning?- that love gets messy, that its okay when it does, and that man I gave my heart to, at such a young age as well, is the same man that I will love eternally.
Till death do us part…
[Reply]
Oh the truth, the reality, the wisdom that is wrapped up in that second choice! And most definitely for us it meant walking away, falling out of love, and then choosing to love again. Knowing what life was like for us apart is a significant ingredient in the glue that holds us together today!
[Reply]
Amen.
I especially like the part about the grandmothers, because it reminds me so much of my own:
“Love is a choice isn’t just something our grandmothers said because it sounded pretty. They didn’t tell the young brides that love grows with age simply to make conversation. They were right.”
Thanks for sharing such powerful truths with such honesty and beauty, friend.
[Reply]
Yes and yes.
[Reply]
FIRST: I have listened to Poison and Wine so much I literally know every inhaled breath by heart. The line that gets me EVERY TIME? “I don’t have a choice, but I still choose you” Goose bumps even as I write.
SECOND: Years ago, when I was a newlywed who was very VERY much doubting the decision to get married (not just to Kyle, mind you, but getting married at all), I heard a random spot on Christian radio where someone said “Love doesn’t keep the marriage together, marriage keeps the love together.” I think I probably thought it was pretty unromantic at the time, but thirteen years later, I fully understand the wisdom. I’ve left Kyle in my mind so many times and I’m confident he has done the same. (Like maybe when I forgot to pay the electric bill last month?! Awesome.) I am thankful for the covenant of marriage to keep us knitted into each other, even when we are resistant, unruly yarn.
[Reply]
Yep, you hit the nail on the head, girl.
[Reply]
THIS is real and true and beautiful. Thank you. The choice embedded deeper than the gold of the ring; the commitment, bumped and bruised but remaining, glistening in the diamond … the choice to keep spinning the ring when all of life spins wild about us and the world says “Just take it off” and our feelings betray truth but our spirit knows, KNOWS, that what remains is not just a ring on a finger but a love grown deep and sure and even more beautiful.
Thank you, again, for pointing to truth.
[Reply]
This is exactly it. I’m almost seven years in, and my husband and I are in the middle (I hope late-middle) of the biggest do-I-still-choose-you we’ve had yet. It is terrible and heartbreaking and sometimes ugly, but in the midst of it I’ve seen the incredible beauty of making that choice, and everything that it means, over and over again.
Such a true and right thing for you to share. And that song gets me every time.
[Reply]
ok, i know this is a gurlie post, but fyi, 43 and counting.
[Reply]
Baby girl…
Thank you for being real. I love you…and John. : )
Love,
mama
[Reply]
I think that most of us are distracted from love. Too many things to do, responsibilities, stresses. I was at a wedding recently listening to the vows and suddenly I was overwhelmed by love feelings for my husband. I felt surprised and then I wondered, are they always there? Maybe I have just forgotten because I am so distracted from him.
Date night. So very, very important.
[Reply]
Yes. This is the real love story, the choosing.
[Reply]
Thank you for being so honest and real. I think a lot of young people are confused about love what really means… it’s making the choice daily. It’s sacrifice and unselfishness. It’s making the conscious choice to love despite all the things that tell you to walk away. It’s realizing that we’re all human and sinners and learning to forgive and forget and continue to give love through it all.
I’ve never been married so I have no “history” or advice but I’ve seen marriages fall apart and then I’ve seen marriages through the rough and watched them come alive again and turn into something most beautiful.
Beautiful song!
[Reply]
I love the journey dear Ash… Watching the video and thinking of the days where we had to pick up pieces just a day at a time and clinging to nothing but hope, say yes to our future. We, in pain, said yes to a love that would be stronger after healing…one day at a time. Ripped apart as two, we are healing as one.. thank you for your transparency, as always <3
[Reply]
Only when I read this did I realise how much my heart was aching to hear it. Your words are soulbalm for this yet-to-be-married lady.
[Reply]
Beautiful post!! Frank and I are going on 8 years this October and the thought of him still gives me butterflies. The love has grown and grown, I couldn’t imagine my life without him. God brought me the man of my dreams and I am so in LOVE it’s wonderful. We have been together almost 12 years and I just can’t imagine a love stronger (other than the love I have for the Lord) than the love we share with each other.
Tiffy
[Reply]
YES. we were made to be friends.
amazing, honest, and beautiful.
love the civil wars.
[Reply]
I just felt like even though you have so many comments, I also needed to tell you how beautifully you write. just found your blog today, and i’m loving it.
[Reply]
This is lovely.
[Reply]
(Side note: I love you chose The Civil Wars with this – they’ve been in my queue for a while, but I only just start listening to them this past week. Addicted ever since.)
[Reply]
Have lurked on your blog for a long time. Although we have little in common, so many of your posts speak to me. In response to this one, thought you would enjoy this:
Sometimes hidden from me
in daily custom and in trust,
so that I live by you unaware
as by the beating of my heart,
Suddenly you flare in my sight,
a wild rose blooming at the edge
of thicket, grace and light
where yesterday was only a shade,
And once more I am blessed, choosing
again what I once chose before.
“The Wild Rose” by Wendell Berry
[Reply]
I got married at 18 and I think that sometimes it doesn’t matter the age! I think the bottom line is that with God all marriages have the potential to go the long haul.
[Reply]
Wow Ashleigh that is all I can say…I remember going through this a few years back and I too Chose Jim because I know that love is always growing and developing and I truly believe until the day we die and then into the eternities that our love grows and that challenges and trials can bring us closer or push us apart.
You have an AMAZING talent for writing!!!
[Reply]